PackLiner vs Garbage Bags for Moving and Storage

Planning an upcoming move or need to pack away belongings for storage? You’ve likely considered using either PackLiners or good ol’ garbage bags to protect your stuff. But which option is actually better? 

In this PackLiner vs garbage bag comparison, we’ll dive deep into the key differences between these two packing materials. We’ll break down when it makes sense to use each one based on protection needs, budgets, and volume. By the end, you’ll know exactly which supply is right for your next move or storage situation.

What is a PackLiner?

A PackLiner is essentially a heavy-duty, extra-large plastic bag or lining designed specifically for moving and storage purposes. Unlike standard garbage bags, PackLiners are made from thicker, more durable plastic polymers like polyethylene or polypropylene. 

This burly construction allows PackLiners to better resist punctures, tears, and moisture compared to their flimsier garbage bag counterparts. Most are also treated with special additives during manufacturing to increase their strength and protective qualities even further.

So how exactly do PackLiners work? The multi-ply plastic lining is inserted into a box or storage container. You then load all your belongings directly into the PackLiner itself. Once everything is packed, you simply pull the drawstring closure tight and securely seal the entire contents package inside the durable plastic casing.

Some of the main benefits of using a high-quality PackLiner include:

– Ultimate waterproof and moisture protection

– Unmatched durability and tear resistance  

– Ability to pack very heavy items safely

– Long-term storage capabilities without degradation

– Reusable and recyclable after use

What are Garbage Bags?  

We’re all familiar with basic garbage bags used for containing and disposing of everyday household trash and waste. But many people also use these inexpensive plastic bags for non-trash purposes like moving, storage, and more.

Traditional garbage bags are constructed from thin plastic polymers like polyethylene or polypropylene. This allows them to be produced very cheaply compared to PackLiners. While low costs are a perk, their thin disposable construction does come with some downsides.

Garbage bags simply aren’t as durable, tear-resistant, or waterproof as PackLiners. Their lightweight plastic can puncture during packing and storage. And due to their single-ply construction, they don’t offer the same long-lasting protection against moisture, mold and mildew over time.  

However, for short-term packing and storing of non-fragile household goods, garbage bags can offer a budget-friendly solution despite their limitations. Just don’t expect them to fully safeguard valuables or prevent damage the same way as a heavy-duty PackLiner.

PackLiner vs Garbage Bags: Key Differences

Now that we understand what each packing supply is and how they function, let’s directly compare and contrast some of the key differences between PackLiners and garbage bags:

Protection Level

As mentioned, PackLiners are constructed from multi-ply, reinforced plastic that is far more tear-resistant and waterproof than single-ply garbage bags. PackLiners can easily handle storing heavy furniture, boxes, and valuables without failure. Garbage bags are flimsy by comparison and prone to drips and leaks.

Capacity and Sizing 

Since PackLiners are designed specifically for moving and storage purposes, they are manufactured in much larger sizes to fit boxes, containers, and furniture. Garbage bags max out around 42 gallons typically. But PackLiners come in sizes up to 95 gallons to accommodate bigger packing needs.

Ease of Use

Both packing supplies involve inserting items and sealing, but PackLiners have convenient integrated tying closures. This allows you to quickly cinch down and lock contents inside with ease every time. Standard garbage bags require manually tying knots that can come undone.

Cost 

There’s no denying that PackLiners are more expensive per bag than cheap garbage bag options. However, the upfront cost is often justifiable for the superior protection and performance. Just a few damaged valuables could easily exceed the cost of skimping on proper PackLiner supplies.

When to Use PackLiners Instead of Garbage Bags

While garbage bags can suffice for basic short-term packing and storage jobs, PackLiners are undoubtedly the optimum choice for providing long-lasting protection in several common scenarios, such as:

Long-Term Storage Protection

Whether storing belongings short-term or long-term, you need packing materials that will safeguard against moisture, pests, tears, and more for months or years. The cheap plastic of garbage bags degrades quickly, leaving your items vulnerable to costly damage over time. But PackLiners can maintain an impenetrable seal for years with zero degradation.

Fragile or Valuable Items

Heirlooms, electronics, antiques, fine art and other fragile goods require maximum shielding during any move or storage situation. The heavy-duty construction of a PackLiner provides unmatched absorption of impacts compared to easily punctured garbage bags. It’s an inexpensive insurance policy to avoid costly damages.  

Moisture and Water Concerns  

Are you storing items in an attic, basement, shed or other area prone to moisture and humidity? The waterproof lining of a PackLiner will prevent any leaks, moisture buildup, mold or mildew problems. Flimsy garbage bags can’t provide the same long-term waterproof protection.

Cost-Effectiveness for Large Volumes

While the per-unit cost is higher, buying PackLiners in bulk is ultimately more cost-effective if you have lots of belongings to pack and store long-term. Why risk potential damages by skimping on garbage bags when your total cost is likely lower with the superior protection of PackLiners?

When Garbage Bags Make More Sense

Of course, there are still some scenarios where basic garbage bags can get the job done effectively without investing in heavy-duty PackLiners, such as: 

Short-Term Storage Needs

If you only need to pack and store items for a very short period measured in days or weeks, standard garbage bags will likely suffice. Just don’t expect them to maintain protection beyond a month or two before potentially degrading, leaking or tearing.

Non-Valuable Household Goods

For packing up common household goods like clothes, linens, toys and other non-fragile everyday items, garbage bags offer a cheap packing solution. Just avoid using them for anything truly valuable, fragile or important.

Immediate Availability 

Can’t wait for PackLiner shipments and need packing supplies immediately? Garbage bags are readily available at any grocery, retail or home goods store in a pinch.

Very Small Moving Jobs

If you’re a minimalist with just a few belongings to pack, paying for PackLiner quality is probably overkill. Grab some cheap garbage bags for minor packing jobs to save money.  

Proper Usage and Pro Tips

Whichever packing supply you opt for, there are some important best practices to follow to maximize performance and safety:

How to Pack and Seal PackLiners

To pack a PackLiner properly, first insert it into the box or container. Pack heaviest items first at the bottom. Distribute weight evenly. Use mattress bags for larger furniture pieces. Leave some air space at the top, then pull the drawstring tight to seal.

Garbage Bag Packing Tips  

Don’t overload garbage bags beyond recommended weight limits or they’ll easily tear. Line boxes with bags before packing. Use high-quality bags without holes. Make tight knots or double-bag if possible to prevent spillage during moves.

Safety Considerations

Avoid lifting overloaded PackLiners alone – they can get extremely heavy. Wear gloves when handling any bags to prevent rope burns or cuts. Pack heavy items on the bottom to avoid toppling. Release trapped air to reduce weight.

Recycling PackLiners and Bags

Most community recycling programs accept bagged plastic film like PackLiners and garbage bags. Simply empty contents and recycle plastics separately by taking them to an appropriate facility.

Top PackLiner and Garbage Bag Brands  

There are numerous reputable brands manufacturing both PackLiner and garbage bag products to choose from, such as:

Top PackLiner Brands

– Duck Brand (Polyethylene PackLiners)

– U-Haul (Plastic and Textile PackLiners)  

– Pratt Plus (Recycled Polyethylene PackLiners)

– Berry Plastics 

Conclusion

As you can see, there are distinct pros and cons to using either PackLiners or garbage bags for your moving and storage jobs. While garbage bags offer an inexpensive solution, their lack of durability and protection means they really should only be used for packing non-valuable household items temporarily.

For anything fragile, expensive or requiring long-term storage, heavy-duty sealable PackLiners are well worth the higher upfront cost. Their tear-resistant construction and waterproof protection simply can’t be matched by flimsy garbage bags. Why risk potential damage or replacement costs down the line?

The old saying is true – you get what you pay for. And when it comes to providing superior defense against moisture, rips, leaks and other hazards, multi-ply reinforced PackLiners deliver vastly better performance than single-use garbage bags. They’ll keep your prized possessions secure throughout any long-distance move or multi-year storage.

So before your next relocation or storage project, take stock of what exactly you’ll be packing up. Determine whether you prioritize short-term cost savings or maximum long-term protection. For hassle-free peace of mind, it’s hard to beat the reliable safeguarding of a high-quality PackLiner. But for basic non-valuables, a sturdy garbage bag may suit your needs just fine.

No matter which packing supply you choose, just be sure to follow proper usage techniques, safety protocols, and recycling guidelines. With the right materials and methods, you can successfully pack up every last belonging without worry. Happy moving!